We have been and still are crating T. It's brilliant! His crate is next to my side of the bed and when I can't watch him and he isn't in the backyard he is in his crate. This is for bedtime, if I'm having a shower, when we're eating tea anytime pretty much that I can't keep both eyes on him.
The theory behind it is then your pup can do NOTHING wrong, he can not make any mistakes because you are watching him and can intercept before he makes a mistake. These mistakes are not just toilet training (although it works beautifully for that) but chewing things up, stealing items of table tops, jumping on furniture or the bed uninvited, ohh the list goes on. If your pup never does anything wrong then he does not learn to do those naughty things or think it is acceptable and you have a fun, happy pup that isn't constantly in trouble or being told off. T has chewed up two electrical cords (unplugged both times luckily) because both times I was preoccupied, once I was grooming the shepherd and thought T was asleep at my feet, he wasn't he was quietly occupied chewing through the vacuum cleaner cord. The second time I got up to go the toilet after playing on my laptop, left him chewing on his toy came back to find he'd swapped the toy for my laptop cord!
It makes toilet training a breeze because your either watching him and when he makes any indication of needing to go to the toilet you put him outside - or - he is in his crate and will whine to let you know that he wants to go out because he won't toilet where he sleeps. It is your aim to make sure the pup never, ever toilets in the house, this should be your number one goal for toilet training. Even being super vigilant he will probably still have the occassional accident and it will be your fault because you haven't seen the signs. We have had three accidents in 4 months, 2 of those in the first few days while I was learning what his signals meant and one on the second week cause I was on the phone and couldn't get off in time to take him outside, nothing since.
The crate must only be big enough for him to lay down stretched out, stand up and turn around unhindered. If you make it any bigger he will find a corner to toilet and you have lost the benefit of the crate. There are two schools of thought about food and water in the crate. We started off with none but now that T is settled and understands the concept he does have a water bowl and some biscuits in there. The water I am sure is contributing to us still having to take him out once a night to toilet but he seems to get very thirsty so I am happy to have to get up cause I want him to be able to have a drink when he wants.
The crate should be seen by both you and he as a place of refuge, it is never used as punishment. Dogs have dens and you are providing him with his own private place to go when ever he pleases or when you need him too. The children should never play with or even touch the pup when he is in his crate - that is his space and should be preserved that way. Lots of treats and praise to start with help to make it a fun place until eventually you can leave the door open and he will go in of his own free will. T isn't quite at that point yet, he will go in for a drink or snack but he won't stay in there to sleep unless the door is closed cause he would rather sleep on the couch :smile:.
You will not get the benefits of a crate by sectioning off an area in the kitchen, place the crate in that area if it is the area you have chosen for the pup; personally I like T next to my bed which is also open to the lounge room so he is part of the action so to speak. If your going to crate he must be within earshot and you must be prepared to get up and take him outside when he asks.
Anyway I have written an epic again - sorry everyone, but it isn't cruel, it really is the best thing you can do for your pup. Just my two cents worth. :smile: