Poodle Forum banner

Are crates really necessary?

12K views 47 replies 27 participants last post by  Rocketagility  
#1 ·
I have never used a crate with any of my other dogs. Of course, they were all very small poodles. I am getting a standard poodle puppy in a few weeks and I see that a lot of people use them. I was planning on using my laundry room as "her room" while she is potty training. It would also serve as a no kids zone so that she would have her own down time. Would this work?

Thanks!

Kim
 
#5 · (Edited)
Crates are never necessary, they're great confinement tools, as is an x-pen or puppy proof room. As long as your pup won't be able to reach any clothing, detergent, cords, etc. in the laundry room, it will work the same way as a crate. The only issues I could see is that your pup may have too much room, and may eliminate in one area and have the rest of the area to play and sleep. That's the real bonus of the crate. The small space prevents pups from eliminating in there, as they won't want to sleep in their pee/poop (unless the pup knows no different like pet store or puppy mill pups).
If the laundry room is large, I would recommend getting an x-pen and cordoning off an area of the room for the pup.

Edit to add: Both my boys were crate trained as pups, but as soon as they were able to be trusted in the house, we have never used them again. With any future puppies, I'll use an x-pen. I find crates are too confining for more than an hour at a time. I think crate training can definitely come in handy (for travelling and such) but I would not say it's necessary.
 
#8 ·
It would be a rare puppy indeed, a rare puppy of any breed who, left alone in a laundry room, wouldn't decide to poop and pee in one corner and then go to another spot to lie down. And the fact that there was poop and/or pee somewhere in there wouldn't bother the dog. The thing that they really hate is having to sit in their own excrement. They really don't like that.

The idea of the crate with the divider is that they have enough room to turn around, but not enough room to poop or pee and then get away from it. So you start off with a small crate when the puppy is small, but you move the divided as the puppy gets bigger.

Another thing, as someone mentioned, if you need to take the dog somewhere like a hotel or visiting friends and it has never been in a crate - its like trying to get a bucking bronco into the crate!!
 
#9 ·
Agreed, I think a crate is a fantastic tool. It means you can always have a "home" wherever you take your dog. I find my puppy sleeps better in the crate than anywhere else, he sleeps longer and better.

Also they are more confined/ less likely to be destructive in a crate. I took my eyes off Darcy for less than 5 minutes the other day, and found him in the bathroom peeling the drywall off the wall! (My baseboards are being replaced so it was easy for him to get a grip). He is also a fan of chewing baseboards. If I left him in a laundry room I dread to think what state I would eventually find it in...
 
#10 ·
Thanks for the info. I am looking at crates. What size would I need for a standard size poodle. Which crates are the best........metal, soft side, hard side etc.

We go to my mother in laws once a month for the weekend so the crate would be really helpful there.

I will look into more information on using the crate for potty training.

I know to feed several times a day and not to free feed. I just feel kinda bad about her being in there and not drinking water immediately if she gets thirsty.:(

How long should you leave them in there at a time? I am a sahm so I am home pretty much all day except for errands which I try to do away from kids on the weekend when my husband watches them.

Thanks!

Kim
 
#15 ·
Yes that would be good. I have one almost identical to that except mine only has one door. You could even get the next size up if you wanted - but that depends how tall your poodle will be.

For being in the crate, the general rule of thumb is about 1 hour for each month they are in age. So an 8 week puppy can hold their bladder for approximately 2 hours, give or take. Every puppy is different. You will gradually increase the time spent in the crate.

Keep in mind that a puppy will do everything possible to not soil its crate, but if it is left in its crate for longer than it can physically hold its bladder, it will have no choice but to unhappily potty.
 
#14 ·
we actually have a water dish that attaches to the crate so Fozzie can drink at night or when we have to crate him for long periods (like going to the theatre). We try never to crate him for more than 4 hours at a time, and take him for a long walk before and after. if it's going to be more than four hours right now, we don't do the activity or we take him to doggie day care. We allow water and we also give him kong or a big new bone too so it's not so bad fo rhim.

He loves his crate at night and insists on going on there, he even makes sure I have closed the locks right. I cover his crate and he zzzzz all night, never even whimpers or cries. He sleeps 8-10 hours a night which believe me when he was younger was a great relief to me. I tried keeping him out of the crate one night and didn'tsleep a wink!

crates are, iMHO, absolutely necessary for those moments when you can't watch him, or for time outs when he's acting really hyper. we would time out with him for 15-30 minutes. Early on we crated him during our meals but now he is trained not to beg at dinner.

I'd have lost my mind without the crate.
 
#20 ·
Personally, I wouldn't give the puppy water while in the crate. Inevitably, if the puppy drinks, it will have to pee. I would give water on a schedule. That way you can let the puppy go potty about 30 minutes after drinking.

Once your dog is older and has better bladder control, that is a different story.

You don't have to use the crate forever. Henry hasn't been in a crate since he was ten months old. (Probably should have been in one longer..he ate quite a few plants in the house..)
 
#16 ·
As a groomer, I wish more owners crate trained their dogs. It allows the dogs to be calmer while drying in a kennel, or waiting for their owners to come pick them up. You can tell which dogs aren't crate trained because they don't stop scratching the sites or barking the. whole. time. they're. there.
 
#17 · (Edited)
I have one dog who doesn't need a crate, one who I kind of trust to be out when no one is there, and one that I cannot trust.

TQ has run of the house when I am gone. She doesn't potty inside, and doesn't tear anything up. I just have to make sure I don't leave out food. Tate is my iffy - I trust him, but I'm not sure I trust TQ to not annoy him the whole time. And, well... last time thegrey was left to his own devices in the house he ate half of a fire log. (It was not pretty coming back out.)

I think crates are a wonderful tool if used correctly and the dog isn't confined to the crate more than necessary. I have wire crates for all of my dogs (in addition to a small plastic one for Tate and the cat), and the two that actually use theirs enjoy going in for quiet time on their own.

As for water, my dogs have what looks like giant gerbil water bottles - made for dogs, of course. They can drink when they want.

Definitely look into using the crate for potty training. My family has used crates for potty training for as long as I can remember. Puppy goes out on leash, "go potty, go potty, go potty", if they do potty, they get "out" time in the house... if they don't, they go in the crate for 10 minutes or so, then you take them back out and encourage them to potty. They go in the crate every time they don't potty, and once they do go outside, they get rewarded for doing their business outside. Puppies catch on fast. (For my dogs, I say "go pee" and then they all pee... then I say "go poop" and they all go poop. It's crazy what they get!)

EDIT: Hope that rambling reply made sense. I just now re-read it. Yikes!

Edited to say, however... TQ and Tate have figured out how to open their wire crates with their noses and paws, so I bought a "backpack" combo lock that I leave with the combination in all the time (it is karabiner style... I just couldn't find a karabiner at the time, one would suffice though!). I loop it near the lock where the door latches to the frame... that way they can't break each other out and they can't break themselves out.
 
#22 ·
Crates are absolutely fantastic training tool as well as a "safety device" when puppy has to stay home alone and also inevitable confinement in the groomers salon as well as at vet's office, not to mention traveling.

I was also looking into crates lately and found this one interesting since it is kind of a "hybrid" between a cage and travel plastic one petadventureoutlet pet gear products

It is collapsable : ))) !!!! It comes with a carrier bag and padded insert is removable and washable.

It is not for air-travel , though...
 
#23 ·
Agreed!! Riley was crate trained as a puppy, and we were able to leave him out after 2 years. This spring he badly injured his leg, as has had to be crate rested since. It was so easy to pull it out again, and he wasnt stressed at all. He will go lay in there on his own still. You never know where/when you will need that skill in the future!
 
#24 ·
I think its essential! I was dead set against crate training Elphie but with some gentle coaxing from my mom I decided it was best to crate train her and thank gosh I did!!
We had a family member pass away in April and if it weren't for the crates ((And a generous neighbor who came to let them out every 3 hours)) our house would have been destroyed during the time we were with our family >.<
 
#25 ·
I agree with all the "yes, crate" people. I have raised dogs both ways. When I was younger, my first dogs were raised without crates.. and, man, could they get into trouble! For years now, all my dogs are crate trained.

Not only does it give you peace of mind that your puppy will be safe while you are gone, the puppy will NOT be learning bad habits that you will not be there to correct such as chewing on anything that is not a dog toy, pottying in the house, getting into poisonous plants/products or chewing on electric cords. Also, they learn that it is their little, personal den. Of course, a dog should NEVER be crated for hours and hours on end... i.e., the crate should never be its "home". But, used properly, the crate is an invaluable tool that helps your pup learn to house train; learn to be in "quite time" when needed; produces good habits of not chewing except on dog toys(any habit a dog does not start, a dog doesn't learn); when you need to travel the dog is already accustomed to the crate so crate time is peaceful and not a howling, screaming mess; if you are visiting family and dog goes with you and dog needs to be put in during hectic times or left with family, then the dog already is accustomed to it; also, if the dog goes with you and finds the new surroundings stressful, having the crate gives your dog a place that is "home and comfort" to it and gives it a place to chill.

There are so many pluses to crate training that I would never, ever be without a crate for my dogs. Obviously, they must be used with common sense and properly and all will be happy. :)
 
#26 ·
I use the crate any time I need to make sure Teddy can't get into anything he isn't supposed to when I'm not around to supervise. I collapsed it and threw it in the trunk for our trip to my parents' house and I'm glad I brought it. We needed to go out one evening and I was able to put him in his crate (where he feels comfortable already because it's his own personal space) and not worry that he would eat the (poisonous) leaves off my Mom's Mauna Loa Peace Plants while we were out.

It's something that you may or may not use on a daily basis, but when you need it, there's really no substitute.
 
#27 ·
Crates . . .



My list of reasons to crate train:
  1. Faster Potty Training
  2. A place that the dog can -really- call their own for rest and 'getting away from it all' I don't think a utility room works quite the same. The can't see anything, and a large puppy can become destructive if accidentally left too long in a room. Utility rooms also have chemicals, soaps, etc that are not usually very good for dogs . . . if he's bored . . .
  3. The rare times when a guest that is afraid of dogs arrives . . or workmen or ...?
  4. In case the dog is injured, you can control his/her movments until you bring him to a vet/e-room
  5. Makes travel (buy a folding crate) very easy. You can leave the room w/the dog in the crate and go for dinner . . . And of course, your poodle will love being with you while you travel.
Crating takes advantage of a natural canine denning instinct, my dogs absolutely love their crate! They go in it on their own when they are tired. Also, I personally have both dogs' crates in the bedroom. They sleep in the same room as we do. Since they are adults, we leave the crate open - but they still call it home! We dont' have a large bedroom, and the crates do take room . . . but we use them as dressing tables and etc . . .
Standard Poodles in particular are excellent guard dogs, and cannot guard you if they are in the utility room! If the boogey man came in the night - there's no way s/he could defend you! (Remember, spoos stopped at the quarter-finals in competition to be the US Army's official guard dog during WWII !!)
It took some convincing for my wife to finally accept crating as a training/lifestyle aid. 'It cruel and blah blah' . . . Not!

Rules to Crate Train By
  1. Never Never EVER use the crate as a punishment . . . only happy tones and treats to start the intro process. Make it a game make it fun!
  2. Never leave a dog in a crate for more than one hour per month old (up to 8 or 9 hours max). E.G. 3 month old == max 3 hours, 5 month old == max 5 hours, 10 months old == 8 or 9 hours max . . .
  3. Never EVER let a puppy out if they are whining or carrying on. If you do, you will almost guarantee separation anxiety as an end result. When you are first crate training, leave the pup in for about 15 minutes. Stay in the room for the first time, and let him out when the time comes and praise/treat. Do that a couple of times and then go onto more time in the crate. Leave the room and close the door(they must learn to be by themselves). Come back in the room with a happy tone . . .if they are not whining and crying - let him out and praise praise and treat! If they whine turn right around and walk out. When the stop whining, immediately - and I mean NOW let them and praise praise treats!! Next time make it 30 minutes . . . same routine . . .then an hour . . 90 minutes . . . you get the picture!
  4. When you come home, do NOT immediately let the dog out of the crate! Wait a bit, don't even acknowledge your dog immediately . . . after 3 or 5 minutes (and NOT when they are whining) take them out of the crate for a potty break and praise all the way there and when they do their deed. As others have said - use the divider to reduce the interior space while they are growing. Make it big enough where they can turn around easily.
  5. When you leave, don't make it a big deal . . .just put the dog up and leave. When you get back - don't make it a big deal . . . very low key just like this normal stuff that happens . . .(it is!) When they get older, you can warm up the greeting . . . just dont' get dramatic while they are younger . . .

Crate them and they'll love you for it!

Mark, Jamie and The Poodle Gangsters!
 
#31 ·
[*]Never Never EVER use the crate as a punishment . . . only happy tones and treats to start the intro process. Make it a game make it fun!
Vegas gets a treat EVERY time he goes in when I say kennel. He doesn't sulk in, he doesn't shy in, he doesn't hesitate.

There's days I work in the morning, and on those days I'll have him in bed with me then crate him before I go to work, that way he's not in the crate all night, out for a half hour, then back in for 5 hours that I'm at work. BUT! He is also 100% housetrained and stays with me the whole night.
 
#29 ·
Another in the yes camp. Crate training made potty training so much easier with Lola (Dixie was already trained when I adopted her) and it also kept her safe through the puppy chewing stage.
Both girls are crate trained and they both love their crates and will often sleep or hang out in them of their own volition. New Spoo will be crate trained through my program and will have one as well.
It is essential in an emergency that your dog can be comfortable in a crate. Whether it is boarding, the vet or an emergency evacuation.
 
#32 ·
I'm a huge crate fan too, even for the adults. It's their safe place. If I have guests over with little kids who are gentle with them, but rambunctious, or if they've just had enough, namely Cosita, she goes into her crate. If there are thunderstorms and she's nervous, she goes into her crate. I love this, because I can't always be there, and I'm not always in a position to make her feel safe. This way she can do it herself, and she's never stressed out to the point of feeling like she has to defend herself. Liberty doesn't use it so much like this because she doesn't really get stressed. If I leave for a while, they go into their crates. They go in all on their own in any of these situations, as well as to nap throughout the day, with the door wide open. I also feed my dogs in their crates, so the other won't eat it. Right now, Liberty's has around 10 stuffed animals in there that she's brought in with her for one reason or another, and Cosita's has 3 blankets. . . her favorites. I used to think of them as punishments, but they're sooooo not. They love them, so I love them. Here are a few pics to show that fact. All these dog beds around the house and she puts herself in there! lol!
 

Attachments

#33 ·
Whether or not you should get a crate for your Standard Poodle puppy depends entirely upon just how much you like your stuff! :lol:

jk, You've received some really great advice here and I'm glad to see you're choosing to use one with your upcoming puppy!
I will never have another dog without a crate. It makes life so much easier.