Thank you all so much for your ideas! We took our puppy, Cali, to PetSmart and had her trimmed up. Thank you so much for pointing out that she will need to get used to the idea of grooming Wonderpup. I didn't think of that. She didn't much like getting groomed by strangers, but she looked so cute when she was done.
Shortly after, my boyfriend decided it was a good idea to shave the hair on her face so she can see better. I'm not a fan at all and loved the way she looked with a fluffy face. Oh, well. It will grow back.