I swear by this and you will like it too. Natural Balance's food logs. They last forever refrigerated and you just slice the amount off you want and break off small pieces as you bait. No mess or residue on your hands after. Sting and all my dogs love that as bait when training. I love Natural Balance dog food as it is but the logs work great for bait. Its like gold.... the dogs love it and its nutricious!Enzo has been difficult with treats. I can't fine a treat that he can chew fast and continue to work with me. I found some but I can't get them locally so I been looking for something easy to chew that is soft. The one treat that has been working is called natures recipe training treats.