Joined
·
13 Posts
Are there Poodles breeders that have the same breeding philosophy that are like Gaylans but for poodles? I'm curious if there's breeders that want their buyers to health test their dogs when the time comes?
I haven't heard of any that do. I like that program, but I don't feel that it is necessary for pet dogs to undergo the same health testing. Golden retrievers have rather poor health as a breed so it may be warranted for them, but is not so necessary for poodles.Are there Poodles breeders that have the same breeding philosophy that are like Gaylans but for poodles? I'm curious if there's breeders that want their buyers to health test their dogs when the time comes?
So, you're saying poodles are healthier than goldens or breeds that are badly bred in gener? I can say that some health testing would be nice for pet dogs like hips and elbows. Maybe von willbrands or whatever it's called would be a nice extra at the very least. Wouldn't it better for the breed to have that on file instead of blackholes in some pedigrees? I tried looking at other breeds and got told that OFA isn't a thing that they do.I haven't heard of any that do. I like that program, but I don't feel that it is necessary for pet dogs to undergo the same health testing. Golden retrievers have rather poor health as a breed so it may be warranted for them, but is not so necessary for poodles.
Yes, poodles are healthier than goldens. Goldens have notoriously poor health, especially in regard to cancer rates. The lifespan of a golden is currently 9-10 years. Standard poodles tend to live a few years longer. I wouldn't say a breed is "badly bred" just because breed health is poor. Generally the issues that caused health issues in our breeds arose many decades ago when genetics were not well understood. Even if a breed is carefully managed currently, past bottlenecks and use of afflicted popular sires can cause high prevalence of health issues. Breeds like dobermans, cavalier king charles spaniels, and bernese mountain dogs all suffer from very poor breed health as well.So, you're saying poodles are healthier than goldens or breeds that are badly bred in gener? I can say that some health testing would be nice for pet dogs like hips and elbows. Maybe von willbrands or whatever it's called would be a nice extra at the very least. Wouldn't it better for the breed to have that on file instead of blackholes in some pedigrees? I tried looking at other breeds and got told that OFA isn't a thing that they do.
So, I can look up stuff on OFA and find it unlike Collie breeders who don't use OFA? That's one of the reasons that made me not want a collie. I know some poodles breeders don't bother testing eyes ever year which bothers me a bit when I check OFA and find that the breeder I'm interested in. IS that a wrong thing to be bothered by?Yes, poodles are healthier than goldens. Goldens have notoriously poor health, especially in regard to cancer rates. The lifespan of a golden is currently 9-10 years. Standard poodles tend to live a few years longer. I wouldn't say a breed is "badly bred" just because breed health is poor. Generally the issues that caused health issues in our breeds arose many decades ago when genetics were not well understood. Even if a breed is carefully managed currently, past bottlenecks and use of afflicted popular sires can cause high prevalence of health issues. Breeds like dobermans, cavalier king charles spaniels, and bernese mountain dogs all suffer from very poor breed health as well.
All good poodle breeders complete genetic testing on parent dogs as well as eye evalutations, and orthopedic evaluations. It's not a black hole in any way. The PCA is very good about encouraging thorough health testing in this breed. In regard to genetic testing, there is really no point in having puppies tested if they are clear by parentage. All diseases that can be tested for are inherited from the parents. If the parent dogs test clear, the puppies will also be clear.
I can certainly think of reasons why it would be interesting and useful to have orthopedic evaluations performed on all puppies. Orthopedic disease such as hip dysplasia is affected by genetics, environment, and hormones. Pet puppies that are spayed or neutered may develop hip dysplasia at different rates than intact parent dogs. Knowing the orthopedic health of these spayed and neutered puppies would be beneficial in advising future owners of possible increased risk of dysplasia due to spay/neuter. But I do think it's something that the breeder should pay for, and should probably also be negotiable.
Yes, generally all good show breeders of poodles should satisfy your desires and keep updated records on OFA. I believe yearly eye exams are required for CHIC certification. You may simply be having trouble finding the good breeders. Full health testing shouldn't be a difficult requirement to meet. We have a running list of good breeders that health test on this site and there are also other sources to find them.So, I can look up stuff on OFA and find it unlike Collie breeders who don't use OFA? That's one of the reasons that made me not want a collie. I know some poodles breeders don't bother testing eyes ever year which bothers me a bit when I check OFA and find that the breeder I'm interested in. IS that a wrong thing to be bothered by?
Do you know of any breeders that pay for that kind of health testing that still breed for show lines and sell to pet homes?
The Collie breeders that I was told to look at don't do OFA because that costs money and they don't want to do it because money by someone that breeds Collies. The same thing happens when I look up the collie breeders on gooddog. And one is USDA inspected which is code for puppy mill. Brookwood Collies - Collie breeder in Danville, PA, 17821 | Breeders.NET I'm not impressed by gooddog at like all if they're suggesting puppy mills to get a puppy from. Do you have any other ideas besides using OFA to look up chic numbers for collies?I just did a quick search for collie breeders near me at gooddog.com, filtering by “excellent,” and found loads.Here’s a breakdown of their health criteria: Guide to Good Dog’s Health Testing Levels
That’s a good place to start a poodle search.
Here are some other good resources:
![]()
🐩 Breeders Listed by Location 🐩 Plus Additional Resources 🐩
GEOGRAPHICAL BREEDERS LIST AND ADDITIONAL RESOURCES PLEASE READ THIS FIRST What this list is NOT: This list is not an endorsement of any breeder by Poodle Forum This list is not a list to just go buy from without doing more investigation This list is not comprehensive What this list IS: This...www.poodleforum.com
I would report a suspected puppy mill through their contact form, assuming they have one. Also be sure to filter by “excellent” while browsing the site. And of course, buyer beware. I would consider gooddog just a starting point.The Collie breeders that I was told to look at don't do OFA because that costs money and they don't want to do it because money by someone that breeds Collies. The same thing happens when I look up the collie breeders on gooddog. And one is USDA inspected which is code for puppy mill. Brookwood Collies - Collie breeder in Danville, PA, 17821 | Breeders.NET I'm not impressed by gooddog at like all if they're suggesting puppy mills to get a puppy from. Do you have any other ideas besides using OFA to look up chic numbers for collies?
CHIC numbers relate to OFA and the breed club health testing standards. The only other place you'll find CHIC numbers for a specific dog is from the breeder, directly or on their website.Do you have any other ideas besides using OFA to look up chic numbers for collies?
Yes, I'm talking about rough collies which OFA isn't a thing for some of them and they're considered reputable by the community. Apparently, OFA costs money that they don't want to pay up for and it's not a thing when I asked a Collie breeder.Yes, generally all good show breeders of poodles should satisfy your desires and keep updated records on OFA. I believe yearly eye exams are required for CHIC certification. You may simply be having trouble finding the good breeders. Full health testing shouldn't be a difficult requirement to meet. We have a running list of good breeders that health test on this site and there are also other sources to find them.
I'm also confused about Collie breeders not using it. I really thought they did use OFA. Are you talking about rough collies?
Looking more near Pennsylvania and Ohio area. I'm thinking Halcyon days Collies might be a good place to ask but who knows at this point since everyone wants a puppy. The waitlists are filled up and might as well be looking at 2024 for a puppy which is assuming that the world goes back to normal.I had to dig around to find some names of Collie breeders but here's some with testing results listed on OFA. I found a show listing so pulled names from that. I can't say that all Collie breeders, or all breeders of any breed participate in testing and publishing results on OFA, but some certainly do
Advanced Search | Orthopedic Foundation for Animals | Columbia, MO (ofa.org)
Advanced Search | Orthopedic Foundation for Animals | Columbia, MO (ofa.org)
Advanced Search | Orthopedic Foundation for Animals | Columbia, MO (ofa.org)
All Collies listed on OFA
Advanced Search | Orthopedic Foundation for Animals | Columbia, MO (ofa.org)
Yeah, not really interested with going with a USDA inspected breeder. Even I know that's code for puppy mill. Wouldn't bother me if it was like a working dog kennel like for hunting or sledding/whatever but a pet breed like collies makes me not interested. Anyway, they say they do but it's more of you gotta talk to me about it which makes me not interested. I'm lazy and rather look stuff up than waste my time in talking to people who don't health test fully.These are the CHIC requirements for Collies (Rough and Smooth).
The breed clubs are the ones who set CHIC requirements, not OFA.
- Progressive Retinal Atrophy (PRA) DNA Test
DNA-based rcd2-PRA test results from an approved lab; results registered with OFA. First Generation Offspring of tested dogs eligible for Clear By Parentage ➚- Multiple Drug Sensitivity
DNA-based MDR1 test results from an approved lab; results registered with OFA. First Generation Offspring of tested dogs eligible for Clear By Parentage ➚- Dermatomyositis
DNA based DMS test results from an approved lab
If you have more than four breeding females, and sell puppies "sight unseen", meaning that you don't physically meet each and every puppy buyer in person when they get their puppy (in other words, you ship a puppy to them without a physical meeting), then you might need to be licensed. https://images.akc.org/pdf/governmentrelations/documents/USDA_Handout.pdf
The breeder you linked has more breeding animals than I'm comfortable with, and some of them are less than stellar examples of the breed, but they say they health test.
A reputable poodle breeder does all the appropriate tests for the variety of poodles that s/he breeds. And reputable poodle breeders will have puppies that they sell as pets since they only keep the very best for show. A puppy from a reputable breeder should cost $2500-$3000 because all that health testing for many generations is expensive!So, I can look up stuff on OFA and find it unlike Collie breeders who don't use OFA? That's one of the reasons that made me not want a collie. I know some poodles breeders don't bother testing eyes ever year which bothers me a bit when I check OFA and find that the breeder I'm interested in. IS that a wrong thing to be bothered by?
Do you know of any breeders that pay for that kind of health testing that still breed for show lines and sell to pet homes?
Ok, I think I've finally sorted thru here. The testing recommended for Collies (smooth and rough) by the parent Breed Club is all DNA testing, no phenotype or physical exams, just DNA.Yes, I'm talking about rough collies which OFA isn't a thing for some of them and they're considered reputable by the community. Apparently, OFA costs money that they don't want to pay up for and it's not a thing when I asked a Collie breeder.
Select Panel | Best Price! Select this panel for only $275.00 A $400.00 value | Why add this panel? Why are panels discounted? |
Click the test name to learn more | |
---|---|
Collie Eye Anomaly Aliases: Choroidal hypoplasia, CEA, CH | |
Cyclic Neutropenia Aliases: Cyclic hematopoiesis, Gray collie syndrome, CH, CN | |
Degenerative Myelopathy Aliases: Canine degenerative myelopathy, DM | |
Multidrug Resistance 1 Aliases: Ivermectin sensitivity, MDR1 gene defect, Multidrug sensitivity, MDR1 | |
Progressive Retinal Atrophy, Rod-Cone Dysplasia 2 Aliases: PRA-rcd2 |
Click the test name to learn more | |
---|---|
Dermatomyositis List Price $170 and 3-4 Week Processing Time from Sample Receipt Aliases: Juvenile Dermatomyositis, DMS, JDM | |
Hyperuricosuria Aliases: Urolithiasis, HUU |
USDA licensing is definitely not a guarantee of a breeder being a puppy mill.USDA inspected breeder. Even I know that's code for puppy mill