PTP, i'd love to hear how you worked on recall. That is still a problem for us, still unreliable. We started out on clicker training, and once the behaviors were ingrained, i didn't use the clicker anymore. But for recall it didn't seem to work out. Could you tell me exactly what you did that worked? Did you click once she had come to you, and then treat, or something else?
I really think the late introduction of clicker training might have been the key for her. We'd already been working on recall for over 6 months. The foundation was there, but the reliability wasn't.
Even now I don't trust it would work in a high stakes situation. That's something I don't expect from her (or any dog) until maturity. And even then, I know there can always be exceptional circumstances.
But I knew we'd made huge progress when she started literally sprinting to me. And that was almost immediately after I introduced the clicker. Once she mentally paired the clicker with reward, she tuned into me on a different level. Every command began eliciting an immediate response.
To start, I just spent a few minutes (my trainer said this process should have actually been days or weeks - oops) doing click, treat, click, treat, click, treat. Then a few minutes doing simple commands:
Sit, butt hits floor, click, treat.
Lay down, elbows hit floor, click, treat.
Repeat, repeat, repeat, always being extremely careful to time the click with the EXACT moment she does the desired behaviour.
Until I introduced the clicker, we'd been working on a more relaxed version of "come" in class, which is basically just her name paired with the word "here." Until then, she'd gotten a high value treat each time she returned to face me, but her response was spotty at best, especially if there was something more fun going on.
But it's been solid since that first clicker session, even when I don't have the clicker. I tried just a gentle "Peggy, here!" when she was playing with her dog friends the other day, when food is usually the
last thing on her mind, and she returned so quickly to me that another owner gasped, "Peggy! Wow!"
During a clicker session, the sequence is always "Peggy, here!" followed by a click the
moment she arrives in front of me. Then treat.
Chicken or cheese work best for Peggy. Sometimes I'll use dry treats like a special kibble she loves, but not if we're doing anything active, otherwise she chokes. Tiny bits of string cheese is the best.
P.S. It's been hard training my husband not to ruin the command by using it for unpleasant things or by saying it in a harsh tone. Even for things she doesn't really mind, I encourage him to use an alternative. So going into her crate, for example, is "In."
I never want her to stop and think, "The fun ends if I obey this command." It should just be an extension of the most fun thing ever.
One way we reinforce the fun, outside of clicker training, is by playing "catch" with her. I call it that because it's almost like we're tossing her back and forth. We do this by standing at opposite ends of a field (or the house), each armed with treats, and we take turns calling her. It's the fastest I've ever seen her run. 😂