I was kind of slow to try it when I first came in contact with it to be honest. I am the type of person who isn't quick to trust I suppose I find things that I like and am very resistant to change. I use the seameal with the poodles and like it. My tibbies have done best on the solid gold wee bites food. Wonder especialy, she's the one who really sold me on the product line to be honest. She went from being skinny, picky, sparse coated dog that I couldn't seem to get in condition to show to being really awsome.
There is still the cost issue which, with a baby on the way, is more important than it once was. I think I may give chicken soup another try, or perhaps wellness?
I lost my source for the solid gold it and the price went through the roof at the only other place I could get it localy so I quit feeding it about a year ago and went to Blue Buffalo. That was when we got our first spoo and I was looking for something to feed a much larger dog that would still be affordable. Now though I have another reliable source for it at a newer pet store so I might switch back to it... then again I might not LoL.
I reccently tried our spoo puppy Saleen on Taste of the Wild and it proved to be disapointing

She'd had such a gas problem on the blue that I was up for a change when somebody here suggested the food. The first formula I tried made her stink, it was the fish one. Ewwww, no matter what I bathed her in her skin just had a fishy odor. I can deal with fishy breath, but not with fishy all over smell. I tried one of the other formulas next and just didn't see anything in her that would suggest she should stay on that food. Bummer.